Library Trends 68 (1) Summer 2019: Learning Analytics and the Academic Library: Critical Questions about Real and Possible Futures

 

Library Trends 68 (1) Summer 2019: Learning Analytics and the Academic Library: Critical Questions about Real and Possible Futures. Edited by Kyle M. L. Jones.


The issue begins with Tami Oliphant and Michael R. Brundin's review of the learning analytics literature and role of big data in higher education, including a detailed review of how libraries are pursuing learning analytics. They home in on the stated values and ethical principles to which librarians hold strong, arguing that such things are seemingly incompatible with the aims learning analytics seek to achieve.


Respectively, the work by Sarah Hartman-Caverly and Karen P. Nicholson, Nicole Pagowsky, and Maura Seale address how temporality, manipulation, and power issues intertwined with learning analytics all act upon students and librarians in ways that diminish their autonomy and exert influence. For Hartman-Caverly, learning analytics are used to engineer student attention in ways that serve the capitalistic interests of higher education institutions. For Nicholson and her colleagues, learning analytics are a form of temporal governmentality. They argue that administrators and the politically powerful can use data analytics to scrutinize real-time performance of students and librarians, predict future outcomes (even when such outcomes are not guaranteed), and advocate for data-based interventions to resolve undesirable predicted outcomes.


M. Brooke Robertshaw and Andrew Asher's article employs a statistically driven meta-analysis strategy of library learning analytics research. The analyzed corpus included common "library value" research that suggests a positive correlation between grade-point average and library usage or library instruction. Robertshaw and Asher found, however, that the effect of such findings is statistically weak, and they argue that the potential privacy harms are not justified by the analytic practices.


Library Trends (ISSN 0024-2594) is an essential tool for librarians and educators alike. Each issue thoroughly explores a current topic of interest in professional librarianship and includes practical applications, thorough analyses, and literature reviews. The journal is published quarterly for the Graduate School of Library and Information Science by The Johns Hopkins University Press. For subscription information, call 800-548-1784 (410-516-6987 outside the U.S. and Canada), email jlorder [at] jhupress.jhu.edu, or visit www.press.jhu.edu/journals.

Recent AdditionsRSS feed

  • Robertshaw, M. Brooke; Asher, Andrew (Johns Hopkins University Press and the Illinois School of Information Sciences, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2019)
    Following trends in higher education that emphasize quantitative analytical approaches to assess educational outcomes, academic libraries are increasingly attempting to quantify their impacts on student learning and ...

    application/pdf

    application/pdfPDF (201kB)
  • Nicholson, Karen P.; Pagowsky, Nicole; Seale, Maura (Johns Hopkins University Press and the Illinois School of Information Sciences, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2019)
    In this essay, we explore the timescapes of library learning analytics. We contend that just-in-time strategies, a feature of late capital modes of production, New Public Management, and future-oriented risk-management ...

    application/pdf

    application/pdfPDF (118kB)
  • Hartman-Caverly, Sarah (Johns Hopkins University Press and the Illinois School of Information Sciences, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2019)
    This article undertakes a literature review to examine learning analytics through the lens of attention engineering. Informed by a critical literature synthesis from the fields of cognitive science, history, philosophy, ...

    application/pdf

    application/pdfPDF (113kB)
  • Oliphant, Tami; Brundin, Michael R. (Johns Hopkins University Press and the Illinois School of Information Sciences, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2019)
    The prevailing rhetoric concerning learning analytics is that its use will support the educational endeavor and make significant improvements to teaching and learning. For academic libraries, learning analytics presents ...

    application/pdf

    application/pdfPDF (83kB)
  • Jones, Kyle M. L. (Johns Hopkins University Press and the Illinois School of Information Sciences, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2019)

    The issue begins with Tami Oliphant and Michael R. Brundin's review of the learning analytics literature and role of big data in higher education, including a detailed review of how libraries are pursuing learning ...

    application/pdf

    application/pdfPDF (42kB)

Collection Statistics