2026-09-20T23:58:38Z https://www.ideals.illinois.edu/oai-pmh

oai:www.ideals.illinois.edu:2142/46768 2023-07-11 col_2142_5131 col_2142_18657 com_2142_5130 com_2142_18656 com_2142_8903

McCarthy, Timothy G. McCarthy, Timothy G. Chandler, Hugh S. Wagner, Steven J. Wengert, Robert G. Goodlin, Blair 2014-01-16T18:01:50Z 2014-01-16T18:01:50Z 2013-12 2014-01-16T18:01:50Z 2013-12 Classical logic and a given nonclassical logic are, by definition, incompatible in some sense. In some cases, this incompatibility is innocuous. In other cases, the nonclassical logic is incompatible with classical logic on a fundamental level, such that the two logics can be seen as rival theories of logical entailment and only one of them can succeed. I will explore the structure of these cases of logical rivalry by considering three examples: Dummett’s antirealism, Putnam’s response to results of quantum mechanics, and Tye’s response to vagueness. I will show that, despite the differences between these cases’ motivations and methods, they nevertheless all conform to a particular framework in challenging classical logic. Moreover, these diverse cases all characterize classical logic as the result of an unwarranted generalization from a limited and apparently privileged realm of entailment. Item withdrawn by Laura Spradlin (lspradl2@illinois.edu) on 2013-12-03T22:03:55Z Item was in collections: University of Illinois Theses & Dissertations (ID: 1) No. of bitstreams: 1 Goodlin_Blair.pdf: 460247 bytes, checksum: 0118bba8275390c168fb926ed4b8e6ed (MD5) Made available in DSpace on 2014-01-16T18:01:50Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 2 Blair_Goodlin.pdf: 460247 bytes, checksum: 0118bba8275390c168fb926ed4b8e6ed (MD5) license.txt: 4062 bytes, checksum: 58bed523fa9534b54720a8a432b2f014 (MD5) http://hdl.handle.net/2142/46768 en Copyright 2013 Blair F. Goodlin Jr. Philosophy of Logic Philosophy of Language Classical logic and its rivals text Philosophy 1715 Philosophy 0332 University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign Dissertation Ph.D. PHD:Philosophy -UIUC 10KS0332PHD