Making sense of the Census: Racial classification and racialization of Middle Eastern & North African (MENA) Americans

Maghsoodi, Amir H.

Permalink

https://hdl.handle.net/2142/125742 Copy

Description

Title

Making sense of the Census: Racial classification and racialization of Middle Eastern & North African (MENA) Americans

Author(s)

Maghsoodi, Amir H.

Issue Date

2024-04-09

Director of Research (if dissertation) or Advisor (if thesis)

Ruedas-Gracia, Nidia

Doctoral Committee Chair(s)

Ruedas-Gracia, Nidia

Committee Member(s)

• Neville, Helen A
• Avent, Cherie M
• Hunter, Carla D
• Awad, Germine H

Department of Study

Educational Psychology

Discipline

Educational Psychology

Degree Granting Institution

University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

Degree Name

Ph.D.

Degree Level

Dissertation

Keyword(s)

• Middle Eastern
• North African
• MENA
• SWANA
• Middle East
• North Africa
• Census
• Race
• Race-Ethnicity
• Racial Classification
• Mixed Methods
• Thematic Analysis
• Demographics
• Demography

Abstract

Middle Eastern and North African (MENA) individuals in the United States (US) are legally classified as White, yet they experience daily racism that contradicts this racial classification. The past decade has seen an increase in MENA communities’ activism to add “MENA” as a federal race-ethnicity category. With this study, I sought to better understand MENA individuals’ experiences when they encounter racial-ethnic demographic forms that either include or omit the MENA box. Using a concurrent transformative mixed-methods approach, I conducted an online experiment to test the effects of the MENA box on various psychological outcomes and the moderating effect of individuals’ commitment to social action on this issue. I also analyzed participants’ short-answer responses to an online survey to better understand how MENA individuals make sense of the Census’ race-ethnicity boxes, in particular the MENA box. This study’s quantitative analyses did not find evidence of an effect of the inclusion/omission of the MENA box on measures of positive and negative affect, US national identity, or state-level anxiety. Qualitative analyses, however, showed substantial differences in the psychological experiences with forms that include a MENA box compared with those that omit it. Using reflexive thematic analysis, I generated four themes to describe how MENA individuals make sense of the Census boxes. Theme 1 (The MENA Box is Humanizing) highlights the humanizing impact of seeing a MENA box included on race-ethnicity forms and the dehumanizing impact of its omission. Theme 2 (Forced Into a Box) illustrates how MENA individuals feel forced into various other (non-MENA) boxes when the MENA box is omitted. Theme 3 (A Signal of Organizational Values) describes how MENA individuals interpret the inclusion or omission of the MENA box as a signal of the humanitarian values of the organization administering the race-ethnicity survey. Finally, Theme 4 (A Lever for Equitable Access to Resources) describes a practical understanding of the MENA box and its relevance to sociopolitical representation. The analyses in this dissertation build on extant research to provide the first systematically-derived understanding of how MENA individuals make sense of their racial-ethnic classification when completing demographic forms. The insights generated in this study show how MENA Americans’ understanding of self as racialized peoples comes to bear on their experiences when faced with racial-ethnic demographic forms. They also illuminate the cognitive and affective processes that inform MENA response behaviors on these forms.

Graduation Semester

2024-08

Type of Resource

Thesis

Handle URL

https://hdl.handle.net/2142/125742

Copyright and License Information

Copyright 2024 Amir H. Maghsoodi

Owning Collections